Delay in the naturalization process:
The action for failure to act before the naturalization
The agency won't make a decision
What should I do?
Your contact
Shahroch Taleqani
Overview
Table of contents
The essentials
- How long?
Processing times are often 18 months or more—due to the heavy workload at naturalization authorities - Requirements:
The application for naturalization must already have been filed, and the authorities have not yet made a decision. - When?
If no decision has been issued within 3 months, a lawsuit may be filed.
Rising naturalization rates and overburdened government agencies
The number of naturalizations in Germany has risen steadily in recent years. In 2024, naturalizations reached a new record high, with a 45% increase over the previous year. In 2024, a total of 291,955 foreign nationals acquired German citizenship.
This can be attributed primarily to the legislative changes that took effect in June 2024. Not only has the required length of residence for naturalization been reduced from 8 years to 5 years, but dual citizenship has also been made possible.
Naturalization authorities across Germany are overwhelmed by the rapidly growing number of naturalization applications , and applications often remain pending for months (and in some cases, even years). In Munich, too, the Service Center for Immigration and naturalization complains about the excessive workload, even though the city employs more staff than ever before. The result is long wait times for applicants.
It is particularly advisable to seek legal assistance from the law firm RT & Partner , which specializes in naturalization law, if your case is being unnecessarily delayed or if communication with the authorities is proving difficult. This is especially true in the following cases:
- Your application for naturalization has not been processed for months.
- Inquiries regarding the current status of the request remain unanswered.
- Personal or professional reasons make it necessary to make a quick decision (e.g., a concrete job offer or family circumstances).
- Repeated attempts to contact the responsible naturalization authority have yielded no response.
- The agency does not clearly inform you about missing documents or requirements that still need to be met.
RT & Partner As a law firm specializing in naturalization, we assist clients nationwide and are committed to ensuring that their cases are handled in a legally sound manner and as quickly as possible.
Timely judicial protection—the advantages of an action for failure to act
Naturalization procedures are often very opaque. When applicants inquire about the current status of their application, they often receive only automated, standard responses. Information on current processing times is often difficult or impossible to find. In such cases, it is advisable to seek legal assistance and let your attorneys handle communication with the authorities.
The purpose of an action for failure to act under § 75 VwGO is to compel the authority to act promptly and thereby avoid long waiting periods. Three months after submitting your application at naturalization, you may file a lawsuit to compel a decision on your naturalization application. You may be represented by our experienced attorneys in this matter.
An action for failure to act thus provides prompt judicial protection. Experience from numerous naturalization proceedings shows that such actions often break the deadlock in stalled proceedings. Once a lawsuit is filed, authorities often resume processing the application shortly thereafter and decide on the naturalization application much more quickly. This trend is supported by current higher administrative court case law, which imposes increasingly stringent requirements on the justification of long processing times.
Requirements for an action for failure to act
In order to successfully file a lawsuit against the inaction of the Federal Office for Consumer Protection ( naturalization authority ), certain requirements must be met.
1. Application already submitted for naturalization
To file a lawsuit for failure to act, you must have already submitted a request at naturalization , and the agency must not have yet made a decision. We have summarized here how to submit such a request at naturalization and what requirements you must meet.
2. Expiration of the three-month period
Three months after submitting your application at naturalization, you may file an action for failure to act with the administrative court. Only in exceptional cases may you file a lawsuit before this deadline expires. You must demonstrate that you have a special interest in the agency’s prompt decision regarding your naturalization and that a longer wait would be unreasonable for you. This would be the case, for example, if you face irreparable harm. You can consult with your attorneys to determine whether this applies to your situation.
3. No sufficient reason for the delay
Furthermore, a prerequisite for an action for failure to act is that the authority fails to render a substantive decision within a reasonable time without sufficient cause. In all cases, an authority must decide on applications as promptly as possible without compromising the necessary thoroughness.
It is up to the authority to prove that there is a sufficient reason for not processing the application.
Possible valid reasons may include:
- an extraordinary burden on a government agency that cannot be addressed in the short term through organizational measures,
- Overwhelming a government agency with a temporary surge in applications.
Insufficient grounds include, among other things:
- A blanket reference to staff shortages or ongoing stressful situations (e.g., the COVID-19 crisis or a mass influx of people seeking refuge from Ukraine),
- prolonged absence of the responsible case worker due to vacation or illness (in such cases, the administration must ensure adequate coverage).
Recent rulings by the Higher Administrative Court have significantly tightened the requirements for naturalization authorities. The rising number of applications and the reform of nationality law have been foreseeable for years, and therefore do not justify long delays in naturalization proceedings. Naturalization authorities must now specifically explain why the organizational measures taken remain insufficient despite a long lead time. According to recent case law, general references to overwork, staff shortages, or digitization are increasingly no longer sufficient.
Therefore, the sooner the authorities can foresee the overload, the greater the expectations are that they will take appropriate measures to prevent structural organizational shortcomings.
Whether such grounds exist ultimately depends on the specific circumstances of each case. If you would like to determine whether the requirements for an action for failure to act are met in your case, please feel free to contact our attorneys.
Procedure for an action for failure to act
If the three-month period since you submitted your application at naturalization has expired, it may be worthwhile to file an action for failure to act with the administrative court. According to a ruling by the Federal Constitutional Court, you are not required to contact the agency again after the waiting period has expired to inquire about the current status of your case or to give notice of your intention to file a lawsuit.
In administrative court proceedings, there is no requirement to be represented by an attorney. This means you can file your lawsuit on your own. If you are unsure whether you meet the requirements for a successful lawsuit, it may be worth seeking legal representation.
1. Filing of the complaint
An action for failure to act begins when the complaint is filed with the administrative court. The complaint must be filed in writing. You may file the complaint by mail with the appropriate court, through a legal representative ( lawyer) who will prepare and file the complaint on your behalf, or in person at the court’s clerk’s office.
2. Acknowledgment of receipt of the complaint
After filing the action for failure to act, you will receive a confirmation of receipt and, as a rule, a bill for the court fees.
3. Statement by the naturalization authority
The court has referred your complaint to the State Office for Migration and Refugees ( naturalization authority ) and has asked it to submit its comments and provide the relevant official records pertaining to your naturalization proceedings. If the agency subsequently responds in writing, the court will forward those letters to you. You may submit your comments on them. Should the court deem it necessary to obtain further information or comments from you or the agency, it will contact you or the agency directly.
4. Oral hearing
In very rare cases, an oral hearing is held. The oral hearing begins with the case being called and the attendance of the parties being verified. The parties are given the opportunity to present any changes or additions to the facts of the case.
A pretrial conference is then usually held. The court shares its preliminary assessment of the facts and the law, taking into account the positions of both parties. As a result, the parties may agree to settle the dispute amicably rather than have the court issue a judgment. For example, the authorities may promise to make a prompt decision on your naturalization application before a court ruling is issued.
5. Consultation and Decision
If no amicable solution is reached, and once all material points have been discussed and the motions have been filed, the presiding judge closes the oral proceedings. The court then retires to deliberate and either announces its decision on the same day or at a later date, or subsequently serves it on the parties in writing. A transcript of the proceedings is also served after the oral proceedings.
Court ruling in the absence of sufficient grounds
An action for failure to act is a specific type of action for performance (Section 42 of the Administrative Court Rules of Procedure). Provided that the requirements for such an action are met—and, in particular, there is no sufficient reason for the agency’s delay—the court will order the agency to make a decision on your naturalization application.
Court decision where there is sufficient cause
If the agency provides a reasonable explanation that the delay in processing is based on sufficient grounds, the court may suspend the proceedings for a limited period. This means that the court will set a deadline by which the agency must make a decision on your naturalization application.
In doing so, the court determines the reasonableness of the duration of the proceedings based on the circumstances of the individual case.
If the authority issues a decision within this period, the main issue shall be deemed resolved or the lawsuit withdrawn. The court proceedings are thereby concluded. If the authority does not issue a decision, the court proceedings will continue and the court will rule on your application for naturalization, unless there are grounds justifying a further extension of the deadline by the court.
How RT & Partner Can Help You
Our experienced attorneys are happy to assist you with your action for failure to act in the naturalization process. We not only represent you in court but also guide you through the entire process. During an initial consultation, we will discuss your chances of success. We will then review the documents you have submitted, and if we determine that the application is incomplete, we will complete it and subsequently request that the authorities decide on the application within a reasonable timeframe. If the authorities do not respond, we will work with you to draft a complaint and file it on your behalf. We ensure that the process proceeds as smoothly as possible for you so that a decision on your naturalization application is made as quickly as possible.
Why Choose " RT & Partner "?
As a Germany-based firm— law firm —our experienced attorneys combine in-depth knowledge of the German legal framework with personalized advice that takes your individual circumstances into account. We simplify the often complex procedures involving citizenship and administrative law and make your path to German citizenship as clear, straightforward, and fast as possible.
With RT & Partner , you gain not only legal expertise but also a reliable partner who will guide you every step of the way.